Is Jack good or bad?

We wrote our opinions last week on whether Jack from Jack and the Beanstalk is good or bad...what do you think???

I think Jack is bad because his Mum told him to sell the cow for money but he sold it for beans. He broke into the giant's house. He didn't listen to his Mum. He stole a hen, gold and a magic harp. Jack also killed the giant. This makes him naughty and bad.
Darby

I think that Jack was good because he got money from the castle and golden eggs and a harp too because they were poor. Jack chopped down the beanstalk and that was the end of the giant which is good because the giant can't kill people now.
Sam Sargent

I think Jack is bad because he didn't listen to his Mum and he also stole the giant's things. He also killed the giant and chopped down the beanstalk with an axe. He climbed up the beanstalk again and again when his Mum said he had to stay home.
Mia

I think Jack is good because everything he stole was actually his father's stuff. He helped his mum who was so poor. He saved the giant's wife because he was trying to kill her and Jack. He was a hero because he saved the giant's wife.
Holly

I think Jack is bad because he came into the giant's house without asking the giant. Jack took a hen without paying and used it for money. Jack is also bad because he didn't listen to his Mum.
Sam Shelling